Gold Medal Software 3/Gold Medal Software - Volume 3 (Gold Medal) (1994).iso/stats/r.arj/NN.FAQ

Internet Message Format | 1994-01-08 | 50KB

From [e-mail] (Lutz Prechelt)
Newsgroups: comp.ai.neural-nets,comp.answers,news.answers
Subject: FAQ in comp.ai.neural-nets -- monthly posting
Date: 1 Jun 1993 07:35:06 GMT

Archive-name: neural-net-faq
Last-modified: 93/05/20

(FAQ means "Frequently Asked Questions")

  ------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Anybody who is willing to contribute any question or
        information, please email me; if it is relevant,
        I will incorporate it. But: Please format your contribution
        appropriately so that I can just drop it in.

        The monthly posting departs at the 28th of every month.
  ------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is a monthly posting to the Usenet newsgroup comp.ai.neural-nets
(and news.answers, where it should be findable at ANY time)
Its purpose is to provide basic information for individuals who are
new to the field of neural networks or are just beginning to read this
group. It shall help to avoid lengthy discussion of questions that usually
arise for beginners of one or the other kind.

>>>>> SO, PLEASE, SEARCH THIS POSTING FIRST IF YOU HAVE A QUESTION <<<<<
                           and
>>>>> DON'T POST ANSWERS TO FAQs: POINT THE ASKER TO THIS POSTING <<<<<

This posting is archived in the periodic posting archive on
host trfm.mit.edu (and on some other hosts as well).
Look in the anonymous ftp directory "/pub/usenet/news.answers",
the filename is as given in the 'Archive-name:' header above.
If you do not have anonymous ftp access, you can access the archives
by mail server as well.  Send an E-mail message to
[e-mail] with "help" and "index" in the body on
separate lines for more information.


The monthly posting is not meant to discuss any topic exhaustively.

Disclaimer: This posting is provided 'as is'.
            No warranty whatsoever is expressed or implied,
            especially, no warranty that the information contained herein
            is correct or useful in any way, although both is intended.

>> To find the answer of question number <x> (if present at all), search
>> for the string "-A<x>.)" (so the answer to question 12 is at "-A12.)")

And now, in the end, we begin:

============================== Questions ==============================

(the short forms and non-continous numbering is intended)
1.)  What is this newsgroup for ?  How shall it be used ?
2.)  What is a neural network (NN) ?
3.)  What can you do with a Neural Network and what not ?
4.)  Who is concerned with Neural Networks ?

6.)  What does 'backprop' mean ?
7.)  How many learning methods for NNs exist ?  Which ?
8.)  What about Genetic Algorithms ?
9.)  What about Fuzzy Logic ?

10.) Good introductory literature about Neural Networks ?
11.) Any journals and magazines about Neural Networks ?
12.) The most important conferences concerned with Neural Networks ?
13.) Neural Network Associations ?
14.) Other sources of information about NNs ?

============================== Answers ==============================

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A1.)  What is this newsgroup for ?

The newsgroup comp.ai.neural-nets is inteded as a forum for people who want
to use or explore the capabilities of Neural Networks or Neural-Network-like
structures.

There should be the following types of articles in this newsgroup:

1. Requests

  Requests are articles of the form
    "I am looking for X"
  where X is something public like a book, an article, a piece of software.

  If multiple different answers can be expected, the person making the
  request should prepare to make a summary of the answers he/she got
  and announce to do so with a phrase like
    "Please email, I'll summarize"
  at the end of the posting.

  The Subject line of the posting should then be something like
    "Request: X"

2. Questions

  As opposed to requests, questions are concerned with something so specific
  that general interest cannot readily be assumed.
  If the poster thinks that the topic is of some general interest,
  he/she should announce a summary (see above).

  The Subject line of the posting should be something like
    "Question: this-and-that"
  or have the form of a question (i.e., end with a question mark)

3. Answers

  These are reactions to questions or requests.
  As a rule of thumb articles of type "answer" should be rare.
  Ideally, in most cases either the answer is too specific to be of general
  interest (and should thus be e-mailed to the poster) or a summary
  was announced with the question or request (and answers should
  thus be e-mailed to the poster).

  The subject lines of answers are automatically adjusted by the
  news software.

4. Summaries

  In all cases of requests or questions the answers for which can be assumed
  to be of some general interest, the poster of the request or question
  shall summarize the ansers he/she received.
  Such a summary should be announced in the original posting of the question
  or request with a phrase like
    "Please answer by email, I'll summarize"

  In such a case answers should NOT be posted to the newsgroup but instead
  be mailed to the poster who collects and reviews them.
  After about 10 to 20 days from the original posting, its poster should
  make the summary of answers and post it to the net.

  Some care should be invested into a summary:
  a) simple concatenation of all the answers is not enough;
     instead redundancies, irrelevancies, verbosities and
     errors must be filtered out (as good as possible),
  b) the answers shall be separated clearly
  c) the contributors of the individual answers shall be identifiable
     (unless they requested to remain anonymous [yes, that happens])
  d) the summary shall start with the "quintessence" of the answers,
     as seen by the original poster
  e) A summary should, when posted, clearly be indicated to be one
     by giving it a Subject line starting with "Summary:"

  Note that a good summary is pure gold for the rest of the newsgroup
  community, so summary work will be most appreciated by all of us.
  (Good summaries are more valuable than any moderator !  :-> )

5. Announcements

  Some articles never need any public reaction.
  These are called announcements (for instance for a workshop,
  conference or the availability of some technical report or
  software system).

  Announcements should be clearly indicated to be such by giving
  them a subject line of the form
    "Announcement: this-and-that"

6. Reports

  Sometimes people spontaneously want to report something to the
  newsgroup. This might be special experiences with some software,
  results of own experiments or conceptual work, or especially
  interesting information from somewhere else.

  Reports should be clearly indicated to be such by giving
  them a subject line of the form
    "Report: this-and-that"

7. Discussions

  An especially valuable possibility of Usenet is of course that of
  discussing a certain topic with hundreds of potential participants.
  All traffic in the newsgroup that can not be subsumed under one of
  the above categories should belong to a discussion.

  If somebody explicitly wants to start a discussion, he/she can do so
  by giving the posting a subject line of the form
    "Start discussion: this-and-that"
  (People who react on this, please remove the
   "Start discussion: " label from the subject line of your replies)

  It is quite difficult to keep a discussion from drifting into chaos,
  but, unfortunately, as many many other newsgroups show there seems
  to be no secure way to avoid this.
  On the other hand, comp.ai.neural-nets has not had many problems
  with this effect in the past, so let's just go and hope...   :->

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A2.)  What is a neural network (NN) ?

  [anybody there to write something better?
   buzzwords: artificial vs. natural/biological; units and
   connections; value passing; inputs and outputs; storage in structure
   and weights; only local information; highly parallel operation ]

First of all, when we are talking about a neural network, we *should*
usually better say "artificial neural network" (ANN), because that is
what we mean  most of the time. Biological neural networks are much
more complicated in their elementary structures than the mathematical
models we use for ANNs.

A vague description is as follows:

An ANN is a network of many very simple processors ("units"), each
possibly having a (small amount of) local memory. The units are
connected by unidirectional communication channels ("connections"),
which carry numeric (as opposed to symbolic) data.  The units operate
only on their local data and on the inputs they receive via the
connections.

The design motivation is what distinguishes neural networks from other
mathematical techniques:

A neural network is a processing device, either an algorithm, or actual
hardware, whose design was motivated by the design and functioning of human
brains and components thereof.

Most neural networks have some sort of "training" rule
whereby the weights of connections are adjusted on the basis of
presented patterns.
In other words, neural networks "learn" from examples,
just like children learn to recognize dogs from examples of dogs,
and exhibit some structural capability for generalization.

Neural networks normally have great potential for parallelism, since
the computations of the components are independent of each other.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A3.)  What can you do with a Neural Network and what not ?

  [preliminary]

In principle, NNs can compute any computable function, i.e. they can
do everything a normal digital computer can do.
Especially can anything that can be represented as a mapping between
vector spaces be approximated to arbitrary precision by feedforward
NNs (which is the most often used type).

In practice, NNs are especially useful for mapping problems
which are tolerant of a high error rate, have lots of example data
available, but to which hard and fast rules can not easily be applied.

NNs are especially bad for problems that are concerned with manipulation
of symbols and for problems that need short-term memory.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A4.)  Who is concerned with Neural Networks ?

Neural Networks are interesting for quite a lot of very dissimilar people:

- Computer scientists want to find out about the properties of
  non-symbolic information processing with neural nets and about learning
  systems in general.
- Engineers of many kinds want to exploit the capabilities of
  neural networks on many areas (e.g. signal processing) to solve
  their application problems.
- Cognitive scientists view neural networks as a possible apparatus to
  describe models of thinking and conscience (High-level brain function).
- Neuro-physiologists use neural networks to describe and explore
  medium-level brain function (e.g. memory, sensory system, motorics).
- Physicists use neural networks to model phenomena in statistical
  mechanics and for a lot of other tasks.
- Biologists use Neural Networks to interpret nucleotide sequences.
- Philosophers and some other people may also be interested in
  Neural Networks for various reasons.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A6.)  What does 'backprop' mean ?

[anybody to write something similarly short,
 but easier to understand for a beginner ? ]

It is an abbreviation for 'backpropagation of error' which is the
most widely used learning method for neural networks today.
Although it has many disadvantages, which could be summarized in the
sentence
  "You are almost not knowing what you are actually doing
   when using backpropagation"  :-)
it has pretty much success on practical applications and is
relatively easy to apply.

It is for the training of layered (i.e., nodes are grouped
in layers) feedforward (i.e., the arcs joining nodes are
unidirectional, and there are no cycles) nets.

Back-propagation needs a teacher that knows the correct output for any
input ("supervised learning") and uses gradient descent on the error
(as provided by the teacher) to train the weights.  The activation
function is (usually) a sigmoidal (i.e., bounded above and below, but
differentiable) function of a weighted sum of the nodes inputs.

The use of a gradient descent algorithm to train its weights makes it
slow to train; but being a feedforward algorithm, it is quite rapid during
the recall phase.

Literature:
  Rumelhart, D. E. and McClelland, J. L. (1986):
  Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the
  Microstructure of Cognition (volume 1, pp 318-362).
  The MIT Press.
(this is the classic one) or one of the dozens of other books
or articles on backpropagation  :->

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A7.)  How many learning methods for NNs exist ?  Which ?

There are many many learning methods for NNs by now. Nobody can know
exactly how many.
New ones (at least variations of existing ones) are invented every
week. Below is a collection of some of the most well known methods;
not claiming to be complete.

The main categorization of these methods is the distiction of
supervised from unsupervised learning:

- In supervised learning, there is a "teacher" who in the learning
  phase "tells" the net how well it performs ("reinforcement learning")
  or what the correct behavior would have been ("fully supervised learning").

- In unsupervised learning the net is autonomous: it just looks at
  the data it is presented with, finds out about some of the
  properties of the data set and learns to reflect these properties
  in its output. What exactly these properties are, that the network
  can learn to recognise, depends on the particular network model and
  learning method.

Many of these learning methods are closely connected with a certain
(class of) network topology.

Now here is the list, just giving some names:

1. UNSUPERVISED LEARNING (i.e. without a "teacher"):
       1). Feedback Nets:
       a). Additive Grossberg (AG)
       b). Shunting Grossberg (SG)
       c). Binary Adaptive Resonance Theory (ART1)
       d). Analog Adaptive Resonance Theory (ART2, ART2a)
       e). Discrete Hopfield (DH)
       f). Continuous Hopfield (CH)
       g). Discrete Bidirectional Associative Memory (BAM)
       h). Temporal Associative Memory (TAM)
       i). Adaptive Bidirectional Associative Memory (ABAM)
           j). Kohonen Self-organizing Map (SOM)
           k). Kohonen Topology-preserving Map (TPM)
       2). Feedforward-only Nets:
       a). Learning Matrix (LM)
       b). Driver-Reinforcement Learning (DR)
       c). Linear Associative Memory (LAM)
       d). Optimal Linear Associative Memory (OLAM)
       e). Sparse Distributed Associative Memory (SDM)
       f). Fuzzy Associative Memory (FAM)
       g). Counterprogation (CPN)

2. SUPERVISED LEARNING (i.e. with a "teacher"):
       1). Feedback Nets:
       a). Brain-State-in-a-Box (BSB)
       b). Fuzzy Congitive Map (FCM)
       c). Boltzmann Machine (BM)
           d). Mean Field Annealing (MFT)
           e). Recurrent Cascade Correlation (RCC)
       f). Learning Vector Quantization (LVQ)
       2). Feedforward-only Nets:
       a). Perceptron
       b). Adaline, Madaline
       c). Backpropagation (BP)
       d). Cauchy Machine (CM)
       e). Adaptive Heuristic Critic (AHC)
           f). Time Delay Neural Network (TDNN)
       g). Associative Reward Penalty (ARP)
       h). Avalanche Matched Filter (AMF)
           i). Backpercolation (Perc)
           j). Artmap
           k). Adaptive Logic Network (ALN)
           l). Cascade Correlation (CasCor)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A8.)  What about Genetic Algorithms ?

[preliminary]
[Who will write a better introduction?]

There are a number of definitions of GA (Genetic Algorithm).
A possible one is

  A GA is an optimization program
  that starts with some encoded procedure,  (Creation of Life :-> )
  mutates it stochastically,                (Get cancer or so :-> )
  and uses a selection process              (Darwinism)
  to prefer the mutants with high fitness
  and perhaps a recombination process       (Make babies :-> )
  to combine properties of (preferably) the succesful mutants.

There is a newsgroup that is dedicated to Genetic Algorithms
called comp.ai.genetic.
Some GA discussion also tends to happen in comp.ai.neural-nets.
Another loosely relevant group is comp.theory.self-org-sys.
There is a GA mailing list which you can subscribe to by
sending a request to [e-mail]
You can also try anonymous ftp to
  ftp.aic.nrl.navy.mil
in the /pub/galist directory. There are papers and some software.

For more details see (for example):

"Genetic Algorithms in Search Optimisation and Machine Learning"
by David Goldberg (Addison-Wesley 1989, 0-201-15767-5) or

"Handbook of Genetic Algorithms"
edited by Lawrence Davis (Van Nostrand Reinhold 1991 0-442-00173-8) or

"Classifier Systems and Genetic Algorithms"
L.B. Booker, D.E. Goldberg and J.H. Holland, Techreport No. 8 (April 87),
Cognitive Science and Machine Intelligence Laboratory, University of Michigan
  also reprinted in :
Artificial Intelligence, Volume 40 (1989), pages 185-234

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A9.)  What about Fuzzy Logic ?

[preliminary]
[Who will write an introduction?]

Fuzzy Logic is an area of research based on the work of L.A. Zadeh.
It is a departure from classical two-valued sets and logic, that uses
"soft" linguistic (e.g. large, hot, tall) system variables and a
continuous range of truth values in the interval [0,1], rather than
strict binary (True or False) decisions and assignments.
Fuzzy logic is used where a system is difficult to model, is
controlled by a human operator or expert, or where ambiguity or
vagueness is common.  A typical fuzzy system consists of a rule base,
membership functions, and an inference procedure.

Most Fuzzy Logic discussion takes place in the newsgroup comp.ai.fuzzy,
but there is also some work (and discussion) about combining fuzzy
logic with Neural Network approaches in comp.ai.neural-nets.

For more details see (for example):

Klir, G.J. and Folger, T.A., Fuzzy Sets, Uncertainty, and
Information, Prentice-Hall, Englewood
Cliffs, N.J., 1988.

Kosko, B., Neural Networks and Fuzzy Systems, Prentice Hall,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1992.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A10.) Good introductory literature about Neural Networks ?

0.) The best (subjectively, of course -- please don't flame me):

Hecht-Nielsen, R. (1990). Neurocomputing. Addison Wesley.
Comments: "A good book", "comprises a nice historical overview and a chapter
about NN hardware. Well structured prose. Makes important concepts clear."

Hertz, J., Krogh, A., and Palmer, R. (1991). Introduction to the Theory of
Neural Computation. Addison-Wesley: Redwood City, California.
ISBN 0-201-50395-6 (hardbound) and 0-201-51560-1 (paperbound)
Comments: "My first impression is that this one is by far the best book on
the topic. And it's below $30 for the paperback."; "Well written, theoretical
(but not overwhelming)"; It provides a good balance of model development,
computational algorithms, and applications. The mathematical derivations
are especially well done"; "Nice mathematical analysis on the mechanism of
different learning algorithms"; "It is NOT for mathematical beginner.
If you don't have a good grasp of higher level math, this book can
be really tough to get through."


1.) Books for the beginner:

Aleksander, I. and Morton, H. (1990). An Introduction to Neural Computing.
Chapman and Hall. (ISBN 0-412-37780-2).
Comments: "This book seems to be intended for the first year of university
education."

Beale, R. and Jackson, T. (1990). Neural Computing, an Introduction.
Adam Hilger, IOP Publishing Ltd : Bristol. (ISBN 0-85274-262-2).
Comments: "It's clearly written.  Lots of hints as to how to get the
adaptive models covered to work (not always well explained in the
original sources).  Consistent mathematical terminology.  Covers
perceptrons, error-backpropagation, Kohonen self-org model, Hopfield
type models, ART, and associative memories."

Dayhoff, J. E. (1990). Neural Network Architectures: An Introduction.
Van Nostrand Reinhold: New York.
Comments: "Like Wasserman's book, Dayhoff's book is also very easy to
understand".

McClelland, J. L. and Rumelhart, D. E. (1988).
Explorations in Parallel Distributed Processing: Computational Models of
Cognition and Perception (software manual). The MIT Press.
Comments: "Written in a tutorial style, and includes 2 diskettes of NN
simulation programs that can be compiled on MS-DOS or Unix (and they do
too !)"; "The programs are pretty reasonable as an introduction to some
of the things that NNs can do."; "There are *two* editions of this book.
One comes with disks for the IBM PC, the other comes with disks for the
Macintosh".

McCord Nelson, M. and Illingworth, W.T. (1990). A Practical Guide to Neural
Nets. Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc. (ISBN 0-201-52376-0).
Comments: "No formulas at all( ==> no good)"; "It does not have much
detailed model development (very few equations), but it does present many
areas of application.  It includes a chapter on current areas of research.
A variety of commercial applications is discussed in chapter 1.  It also
includes a program diskette with a fancy graphical interface (unlike the
PDP diskette)".

Orchard, G.A. & Phillips, W.A. (1991). Neural Computation: A
Beginner's Guide. Lawrence Earlbaum Associates: London.
Comments: "Short user-friendly introduction to the area, with a
non-technical flavour. Apparently accompanies a software package, but I
haven't seen that yet".

Wasserman, P. D. (1989). Neural Computing: Theory & Practice.
Van Nostrand Reinhold: New York. (ISBN 0-442-20743-3)
Comments: "Wasserman flatly enumerates some common architectures from an
engineer's perspective ('how it works') without ever addressing the underlying
fundamentals ('why it works') - important basic concepts such as clustering,
principal components or gradient descent are not treated.  It's also full of
errors, and unhelpful diagrams drawn with what appears to be PCB board layout
software from the '70s. For anyone who wants to do active research in the
field I consider it quite inadequate"; "Okay, but too shallow"; "Quite
easy to understand";
"The best bedtime reading for Neural Networks.  I have given
this book to numerous collegues who want to know NN basics, but who never
plan to implement anything.  An excellent book to give your manager."


2.) The classics:

Kohonen, T. (1984). Self-organization and Associative Memory. Springer-Verlag:
New York. (2nd Edition: 1988; 3rd edition: 1989).
Comments: "The section on Pattern mathematics is excellent."

Rumelhart, D. E. and McClelland, J. L. (1986). Parallel Distributed
Processing: Explorations in the Microstructure of Cognition (volumes 1 & 2).
The MIT Press.
Comments: "As a computer scientist I found the two Rumelhart and McClelland
books really heavy going and definitely not the sort of thing to read if you
are a beginner."; "It's quite readable, and affordable (about $65 for both
volumes)."; "THE Connectionist bible.".


3.) Introductory journal articles:

Hinton, G. E. (1989). Connectionist learning procedures.
Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 40, pp. 185--234.
Comments: "One of the better neural networks overview papers, although the
distinction between network topology and learning algorithm is not always
very clear.  Could very well be used as an introduction to neural networks."

Knight, K. (1990). Connectionist, Ideas and Algorithms. Communications of
the ACM. November 1990. Vol.33 nr.11, pp 59-74.
Comments:"A good article, while it is for most people easy to find a copy of
this journal."

Kohonen, T. (1988). An Introduction to Neural Computing. Neural Networks,
vol. 1, no. 1. pp. 3-16.
Comments: "A general review".


4.) Not-quite-so-introductory literature:

Anderson, J. A. and Rosenfeld, E. (Eds). (1988). Neurocomputing:
Foundations of Research. The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
Comments: "An expensive book, but excellent for reference. It is a
collection of reprints of most of the major papers in the field.";

Anderson, J. A., Pellionisz, A. and Rosenfeld, E. (Eds). (1990).
Neurocomputing 2: Directions for Research. The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
Comments: "The sequel to their well-known Neurocomputing book."

Caudill, M. and Butler, C. (1990). Naturally Intelligent Systems.
MIT Press: Cambridge, Massachusetts. (ISBN 0-262-03156-6).
Comments: "I guess one of the best books I read"; "May not be suited for
people who want to do some research in the area".

Khanna, T. (1990). Foundations of Neural Networks. Addison-Wesley: New York.
Comments: "Not so bad (with a page of erroneous formulas (if I remember
well), and #hidden layers isn't well described)."; "Khanna's intention
in writing his book with math analysis should be commended but he
made several mistakes in the math part".

Levine, D. S. (1990). Introduction to Neural and Cognitive Modeling.
Lawrence Erlbaum: Hillsdale, N.J.
Comments: "Highly recommended".

Lippmann, R. P. (April 1987). An introduction to computing with neural nets.
IEEE Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing Magazine. vol. 2,
no. 4, pp 4-22.
Comments: "Much acclaimed as an overview of neural networks, but rather
inaccurate on several points.  The categorization into binary and continuous-
valued input neural networks is rather arbitrary, and may work confusing for
the unexperienced reader.  Not all networks discussed are of equal importance."

Maren, A., Harston, C. and Pap, R., (1990). Handbook of Neural Computing
Applications.  Academic Press. ISBN: 0-12-471260-6. (451 pages)
Comments: "They cover a broad area"; "Introductory with suggested
applications implementation".

Pao, Y. H. (1989). Adaptive Pattern Recognition and Neural Networks
Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc. (ISBN 0-201-12584-6)
Comments: "An excellent book that ties together classical approaches
to pattern recognition with Neural Nets.  Most other NN books do not
even mention conventional approaches."

Rumelhart, D. E., Hinton, G. E. and Williams, R. J. (1986). Learning
representations by back-propagating errors. Nature, vol 323 (9 October),
pp. 533-536.
Comments: "Gives a very good potted explanation of backprop NN's. It gives
sufficient detail to write your own NN simulation."

Simpson, P. K. (1990). Artificial Neural Systems: Foundations, Paradigms,
Applications and Implementations. Pergamon Press: New York.
Comments: "Contains a very useful 37 page bibliography. A large number of
paradigms are presented. On the negative side the book is very shallow.
Best used as a complement to other books".

Zeidenberg. M. (1990). Neural Networks in Artificial Intelligence.
Ellis Horwood, Ltd., Chichester.
Comments: "Gives the AI point of view".

Zornetzer, S. F., Davis, J. L. and Lau, C. (1990). An Introduction to
Neural and Electronic Networks. Academic Press. (ISBN 0-12-781881-2)
Comments: "Covers quite a broad range of topics (collection of
articles/papers )."; "Provides a primer-like introduction and overview for
a broad audience, and employs a strong interdisciplinary emphasis".

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A11.) Any journals and magazines about Neural Networks ?


[to be added: comments on speed of reviewing and publishing,
              whether they accept TeX format or ASCII by e-mail, etc.]

A. Dedicated Neural Network Journals:
=====================================

Title:      Neural Networks
Publish: Pergamon Press
Address: Pergamon Journals Inc., Fairview Park, Elmsford,
     New York 10523, USA and Pergamon Journals Ltd.
     Headington Hill Hall, Oxford OX3, 0BW, England
Freq.:      6 issues/year (vol. 1 in 1988)
Cost/Yr: Free with INNS membership ($45?), Individual $65, Institution $175
ISSN #:     0893-6080
Remark:  Official Journal of International Neural Network Society (INNS).
     Contains Original Contributions, Invited Review Articles, Letters
     to Editor, Invited Book Reviews, Editorials, Announcements and INNS
     News, Software Surveys.  This is probably the most popular NN journal.
     (Note: Remarks supplied by Mike Plonski "[e-mail]")
-------
Title:     Neural Computation
Publish: MIT Press
Address: MIT Press Journals, 55 Hayward Street Cambridge,
     MA 02142-9949, USA, Phone: [phone]
Freq.:     Quarterly (vol. 1 in 1989)
Cost/Yr: Individual $45, Institution $90, Students $35; Add $9 Outside USA
ISSN #:     0899-7667
Remark:  Combination of Reviews (10,000 words), Views (4,000 words)
     and Letters (2,000 words).  I have found this journal to be of
     outstanding quality.
     (Note: Remarks supplied by Mike Plonski "[e-mail]")
-----
Title:      IEEE Transaction on Neural Networks
Publish: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
Address: IEEE Service Cemter, 445 Hoes Lane, P.O. Box 1331, Piscataway, NJ,
     08855-1331 USA. Tel: [phone]
Cost/Yr: $10 for Members belonging to participating IEEE societies
Freq.:   Quarterly (vol. 1 in March 1990)
Remark:     Devoted to the science and technology of neural networks
     which disclose significant  technical knowledge, exploratory
     developments and applications of neural networks from biology to
     software to hardware.  Emphasis is on artificial neural networks.
     Specific aspects include self organizing systems, neurobiological
     connections, network dynamics and architecture, speech recognition,
     electronic and photonic implementation, robotics and controls.
     Includes Letters concerning new research results.
     (Note: Remarks are from journal announcement)
-----
Title:     International Journal of Neural Systems
Publish: World Scientific Publishing
Address: USA: World Scientific Publishing Co., 687 Hartwell Street, Teaneck,
     NJ 07666. Tel: [phone]; Eurpoe: World Scientific Publishing
     Co. Pte. Ltd., 73 Lynton Mead, Totteridge, London N20-8DH, England.
     Tel: [phone]; Other: World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd.,
     Farrer Road, P.O. Box 128, Singapore 9128. Tel: [phone]
Freq.:     Quarterly (Vol. 1 in 1990?)
Cost/Yr: Individual $42, Institution $88 (plus $9-$17 for postage)
ISSN #:     0129-0657 (IJNS)
Remark:  The International Journal of Neural Systems is a quarterly journal
     which covers information processing in natural and artificial neural
     systems. It publishes original contributions on all aspects of this
     broad subject which involves physics, biology, psychology, computer
     science and engineering. Contributions include research papers,
     reviews and short communications.  The journal presents a fresh
     undogmatic attitude towards this multidisciplinary field with the
     aim to be a forum for novel ideas and improved understanding of
     collective and cooperative phenomena with computational capabilities.
     (Note: Remarks supplied by B. Lautrup (editor),
     "[e-mail]" )
         Review is reported to be very slow.
------
Title:     Neural Network News
Publish: AIWeek Inc.
Address: Neural Network News, 2555 Cumberland Parkway, Suite 299, Atlanta, GA
     30339 USA. Tel: [phone]
Freq.:     Monthly (beginning September 1989)
Cost/Yr: USA and Canada $249, Elsewhere $299
Remark:     Commericial Newsletter
------
Title:   Network: Computation in Neural Systems
Publish: IOP Publishing Ltd
Address: Europe: IOP Publishing Ltd, Techno House, Redcliffe Way, Bristol
     BS1 6NX, UK; IN USA: American Institute of Physics, Subscriber
     Services 500 Sunnyside Blvd., Woodbury, NY  11797-2999
Freq.:     Quarterly (1st issue 1990)
Cost/Yr: USA: $180,  Europe: 110 pounds
Remark:     Description: "a forum for integrating theoretical and experimental
     findings across relevant interdisciplinary boundaries."  Contents:
     Submitted articles reviewed by two technical referees  paper's
     interdisciplinary format and accessability."  Also Viewpoints and
     Reviews commissioned by the editors, abstracts (with reviews) of
     articles published in other journals, and book reviews.
     Comment: While the price discourages me (my comments are based upon
     a free sample copy), I think that the journal succeeds very well.  The
     highest density of interesting articles I have found in any journal.
     (Note: Remarks supplied by brandt kehoe "[e-mail]")
------
Title:   Connection Science: Journal of Neural Computing,
     Artificial Intelligence and Cognitive Research
Publish: Carfax Publishing
Address: Europe: Carfax Publishing Company, P. O. Box 25, Abingdon,
     Oxfordshire  OX14 3UE, UK.  USA: Carafax Publishing Company,
     85 Ash Street, Hopkinton, MA 01748
Freq.:   Quarterly (vol. 1 in 1989)
Cost/Yr: Individual $82, Institution $184, Institution (U.K.) 74 pounds
-----
Title:      International Journal of Neural Networks
Publish: Learned Information
Freq.:      Quarterly (vol. 1 in 1989)
Cost/Yr: 90 pounds
ISSN #:     0954-9889
Remark:  The journal contains articles, a conference report (at least the
     issue I have), news and a calendar.
     (Note: remark provided by J.R.M. Smits "[e-mail]")
-----
Title:      Concepts in NeuroScience
Publish: World Scientific Publishing
Address: Same Address (?) as for International Journal of Neural Systems
Freq.:      Twice per year (vol. 1 in 1989)
Remark:     Mainly Review Articles(?)
     (Note: remarks by Osamu Saito "[e-mail]")
-----
Title:      International Journal of Neurocomputing
Publish: ecn Neurocomputing GmbH
Freq.:      Quarterly (vol. 1 in 1989)
Remark:  Commercial journal, not the academic periodicals
     (Note: remarks by Osamu Saito "[e-mail]")
         Review has been reported to be fast (less than 3 months)
-----
Title:     Neurocomputers
Publish: Gallifrey Publishing
Address: Gallifrey Publishing, PO Box 155, Vicksburg, Michigan, 49097, USA
     Tel: [phone]
Freq.     Monthly (1st issue 1987?)
ISSN #:     0893-1585
Editor:     Derek F. Stubbs
Cost/Yr: $32 (USA, Canada), $48 (elsewhere)
Remark:     I only have one exemplar so I cannot give you much detail about
         the contents. It is a very small one (12 pages) but it has a lot
         of (short) information in it about e.g. conferences, books,
         (new) ideas etc.  I don't think it is very expensive but I'm not sure.
     (Note: remark provided by J.R.M. Smits "[e-mail]")
------
Title:   JNNS Newsletter (Newsletter of the Japan Neural Network Society)
Publish: The Japan Neural Network Society
Freq.:   Quarterly (vol. 1 in 1989)
Remark:  (IN JAPANESE LANGUAGE) Official Newsletter of the Japan Neural
     Network Society(JNNS)
     (Note: remarks by Osamu Saito "[e-mail]")
-------
Title:     Neural Networks Today
Remark:     I found this title in a bulletin board of october last year.
         It was a message of Tim Pattison, [e-mail]
     (Note: remark provided by J.R.M. Smits "[e-mail]")
-----
Title:     Computer Simulations in Brain Science
-----
Title:   Internation Journal of Neuroscience
-----
Title:   Neural Network Computation
Remark:     Possibly the same as "Neural Computation"
-----
Title:   Neural Computing and Applications
Freq.:   Quarterly
Publish: Springer Verlag
Cost/yr: 120 Pounds
Remark:  Is the journal of the Neural Computing Applications Forum.
         Publishes original research and other information
         in the field of practical applications of neural computing.

B. NN Related Journals
======================

Title:      Complex Systems
Publish: Complex Systems Publications
Address: Complex Systems Publications, Inc., P.O. Box 6149, Champaign,
     IL 61821-8149, USA
Freq.:     6 times per year (1st volume is 1987)
ISSN #:     0891-2513
Cost/Yr: Individual $75, Institution $225
Remark:  Journal COMPLEX SYSTEMS  devotes to the rapid publication of research
     on the science, mathematics, and engineering of systems with simple
     components but complex overall behavior. Send mail to
     "[e-mail]" for additional info.
     (Remark is from announcement on Net)
-----
Title:      Biological Cybernetics (Kybernetik)
Publish: Springer Verlag
Remark:  Monthly (vol. 1 in 1961)
-----
Title:      Various IEEE Transactions and Magazines
Publish: IEEE
Remark:  Primarily see IEEE Trans. on System, Man and Cybernetics; Various
     Special Issues: April 1990 IEEE Control Systems Magazine.; May 1989
     IEEE Trans. Circuits and Systems.; July 1988 IEEE Trans. Acoust.
     Speech Signal Process.
-----
Title:   The Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence
Publish: Taylor & Francis, Ltd.
Address: London, New York, Philadelphia
Freq.:     ? (1st issue Jan 1989)
Remark:     For submission information, please contact either of the editors:
     Eric Dietrich                           Chris Fields
     PACSS - Department of Philosophy        Box 30001/3CRL
     SUNY Binghamton                         New Mexico State University
     Binghamton, NY 13901                    Las Cruces, NM 88003-0001
     [e-mail]     [e-mail]
-----
Title:     The Behavioral and Brain Sciences
Publish: Cambridge University Press
Remark:     (Expensive as hell, I'm sure.)
     This is a delightful journal that encourages discussion on a
     variety of controversial topics.  I have especially enjoyed reading
     some papers in there by Dana Ballard and Stephen Grossberg (separate
     papers, not collaborations) a few years back.  They have a really neat
     concept:  they get a paper, then invite a number of noted scientists
     in the field to praise it or trash it.  They print these commentaries,
     and give the author(s) a chance to make a rebuttal or concurrence.
     Sometimes, as I'm sure you can imagine, things get pretty lively.  I'm
     reasonably sure they are still at it--I think I saw them make a call
     for reviewers a few months ago.  Their reviewers are called something
     like Behavioral and Brain Associates, and I believe they have to be
     nominated by current associates, and should be fairly well established
     in the field.  That's probably more than I really know about it but
     maybe if you post it someone who knows more about it will correct any
     errors I have made.  The main thing is that I liked the articles I
     read. (Note: remarks by Don Wunsch <[e-mail]>)
-----
Title:      International Journal of Applied Intelligence
Publish: Kluwer Academic Publishers
Remark:  first issue in 1990(?)
-----
Title:      Bulletin of Mathematica Biology
-----
Title:   Intelligence
-----
Title:      Journal of Mathematical Biology
-----
Title:      Journal of Complex System
-----
Title:   AI Expert
Publish: Miller Freeman Publishing Co., for subscription call ++415-267-7672.
Remark:  Regularly includes ANN related articles, product
         announcements, and application reports.
         Listings of ANN programs are available on AI Expert affiliated BBS's
-----
Title:   International Journal of Modern Physics C
Publish: World Scientific Publ. Co.
         Farrer Rd. P.O.Box 128, Singapore 9128
         or: 687 Hartwell St., Teaneck, N.J. 07666 U.S.A
         or: 73 Lynton Mead, Totteridge, London N20 8DH, England
Freq:    published quarterly
Eds:     G. Fox, H. Herrmann and K. Kaneko
-----
Title:   Machine Learning
Publish: Kluwer Academic Publishers
Address: Kluwer Academic Publishers
         P.O. Box 358
         Accord Station
         Hingham, MA 02018-0358 USA
Freq.:     Monthly (8 issues per year; increasing to 12 in 1993)
Cost/Yr: Individual $140 (1992); Member of AAAI or CSCSI $88
Remark:     Description: Machine Learning is an international forum for
         research on computational approaches to learning.  The journal
     publishes articles reporting substantive research results on a
         wide range of learning methods applied to a variety of task
         domains.  The ideal paper will make a theoretical contribution
         supported by a computer implementation.
         The journal has published many key papers in learning theory,
         reinforcement learning, and decision tree methods.  Recently
         it has published a special issue on connectionist approaches
         to symbolic reasoning.  The journal regularly publishes
         issues devoted to genetic algorithms as well.
-----
Title:   Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General
Publish: Inst. of Physics, Bristol
Freq:    24 issues per year.
Remark:  Statistical mechanics aspects of neural networks
         (mostly Hopfield models).

-----
Title:   Physical Review A: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics
Publish: The American Physical Society (Am. Inst. of Physics)
Freq:    Monthly
Remark:  Statistical mechanics of neural networks.


C. Journals loosely related to NNs
==================================

JOURNAL OF COMPLEXITY
(Must rank alongside Wolfram's Complex Systems)

IEEE ASSP Magazine
(April 1987 had the Lippmann intro. which everyone likes to cite)

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
(Vol 40, September 1989 had the survey paper by Hinton)

COGNITIVE SCIENCE
(the Boltzmann machine paper by Ackley et al appeared here in Vol 9, 1983)

COGNITION
(Vol 28, March 1988 contained the Fodor and Pylyshyn critique of connectionism)

COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY
(no comment!)

JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICAL PSYCHOLOGY
(several good book reviews)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A12.) The most important conferences concerned with Neural Networks ?

[preliminary]
[to be added: has taken place how often yet; most emphasized topics;
 where to get proceedings ]

A. Dedicated Neural Network Conferences:
   1. Neural Information Processing Systems (NIPS)
      Annually in Denver, Colorado; late November or early December
   2. International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN)
      co-sponsored by INNS and IEEE
   3. Annual Conference on Neural Networks (ACNN)
   4. International Conference on Artificial Neural Networks (ICANN)
      Annually in Europe(?), 1992 in Brighton
      Major conference of European Neur. Netw. Soc. (ENNS)

B. Other Conferences
   1. International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI)
   2. Intern. Conf. on Acustics, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP)
   3. Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society
   4. [Vision Conferences?]

C. Pointers to Conferences
   1. The journal "Neural Networks" has a long list of conferences,
      workshops and meetings in each issue.
      This is quite interdisciplinary.
   2. There is a regular posting on comp.ai.neural-nets from Paultje Bakker:
      "Upcoming Neural Network Conferences", which lists names, dates,
      locations, contacts, and deadlines.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A13.) Neural Network Associations ?

[Is this data still correct ?  Who will send me some update ?]

1. International Neural Network Society (INNS).
   INNS membership includes subscription to "Neural Networks",
   the official journal of the society.
   Membership is $55 for non-students and $45 for students per year.
   Address: INNS Membership, P.O. Box 491166, Ft. Washington, MD 20749.

2. International Student Society for Neural Networks (ISSNNets).
   Membership is $5 per year.
   Address:  ISSNNet, Inc., P.O. Box 15661, Boston, MA 02215  USA

3. Women In Neural Network Research and technology (WINNERS).
   Address: WINNERS, c/o Judith Dayhoff, 11141 Georgia Ave., Suite 206,
            Wheaton, MD 20902.  Telephone: [phone].

4. European Neural Network Society (ENNS)

5. Japanese Neural Network Society (JNNS)
   Address: Japanese Neural Network Society
        Department of Engineering, Tamagawa University,
        6-1-1, Tamagawa Gakuen, Machida City, Tokyo,
        194 JAPAN
        Phone: [phone],    Fax: [phone]

6. Association des Connexionnistes en THese (ACTH)
   (the French Student Association for Neural Networks)
   Membership is 100 FF per year
   Activities : newsletter, conference (every year), list of members...
   Address : ACTH - Le Castelnau R2
             23 avenue de la Galline
             34170 Castelnau-le-Lez
             FRANCE
   Contact : [e-mail]

7. Neurosciences et Sciences de l'Ingenieur (NSI)
   Biology & Computer Science
   Activity : conference (every year)
   Address : NSI - TIRF / INPG
             46 avenue Felix Viallet
             38031 Grenoble Cedex
             FRANCE


------------------------------------------------------------------------

-A14.) Other sources of information about NNs ?

1. Neuron Digest
   Internet Mailing List.  From the welcome blurb:
     "Neuron-Digest is a list (in digest form) dealing with all aspects
      of neural networks (and any type of network or neuromorphic system)"
   Moderated by Peter Marvit.
   To subscribe, send email to [e-mail]
   comp.ai.neural-net readers also find the messages in that newsgroup
   in the form of digests.

2. Usenet groups comp.ai.neural-nets (Oha !  :-> )
             and comp.theory.self-org-sys
   There is a periodic posting on comp.ai.neural-nets sent by
   [e-mail] (Gregory Aharonian) about Neural Network
   patents.

3. Central Neural System Electronic Bulletin Board
   Modem: 509-627-6CNS; Sysop: Wesley R. Elsberry;
   P.O. Box 1187, Richland, WA 99352; [e-mail]
   Available thrugh FidoNet, RBBS-Net, and other EchoMail compatible
   bulletin board systems as NEURAL_NET echo.

4. USENET newsgroup comp.org.issnnet
   Forum for discussion of academic/student-related issues in NNs, as
   well as information on ISSNNet (see A13) and its activities.


------------------------------------------------------------------------



That's all folks.

========================================================================

Acknowledgements: Thanks to all the people who helped to get the stuff
                  above into the posting. I cannot name them all, because
                  I would make far too many errors then. :->

                  No ?  Not good ?  You want individual credit ?
                  OK, OK. I'll try to name them all. But: no guarantee....

  THANKS FOR HELP TO:
(in alphabetical order of email adresses, I hope)

Allen Bonde <[e-mail]>
Alexander Linden <[e-mail]>
S.Taimi Ames <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Kim L. Blackwell <[e-mail]>
Paul Bakker <[e-mail]>
Yijun Cai <[e-mail]>
L. Leon Campbell <[e-mail]>
David DeMers <[e-mail]>
Denni Rognvaldsson <[e-mail]>
Wesley R. Elsberry <[e-mail]>
Frank Schnorrenberg <[e-mail]>
Gary Lawrence Murphy <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Glen Clark <opto![e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Jean-Denis Muller <[e-mail]>
Jonathan Kamens <[e-mail]>
Jon Gunnar Solheim <[e-mail]>
Josef Nelissen <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Luke Koops <[e-mail]>
William Mackeown <[e-mail]>
Peter Marvit <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Yoshiro Miyata <[e-mail]>
Jyrki Alakuijala <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Maciek Sitnik <[e-mail]>
R. Steven Rainwater <[e-mail]>
Michael Plonski <[e-mail]>
[myself]
Richard Andrew Miles Outerbridge <[e-mail]>
Richard Cornelius <[e-mail]>
Rob Cunningham <[e-mail]>
Osamu Saito <[e-mail]>
Ted Stockwell <[e-mail]>
Thomas G. Dietterich <[e-mail]>
[e-mail]
Ulrich Wendl <[e-mail]>
Matthew P Wiener <[e-mail]>

Bye

  Lutz

--
Lutz Prechelt   (email: [e-mail])            | Whenever you
Institut fuer Programmstrukturen und Datenorganisation  | complicate things,
Universitaet Karlsruhe;  D-7500 Karlsruhe 1;  Germany   | they get
(Voice: ++49/721/608-4068, FAX: ++49/721/694092)        | less simple.